MAGE-encoded antigens, which are expressed by tumors of many histological types but not in normal tissues, are suitable candidates for vaccine-based immunotherapy of cancers. Thus far, however, T-cell responses to MAGE antigens have been detected only occasionally in cancer patients. In contrast, by using HLA/peptide fluorescent tetramers, we have observed recently that CD8⁺ T cells specific for peptide MAGE-A10_254–262 can be detected frequently in peptide-stimulated peripheral blood mononuclear cells from HLA-A2-expressing melanoma patients and healthy donors. On the basis of these results, antitumoral vaccination trials using peptide MAGE-A10_254–262 have been implemented recently. In the present study, we have characterized MAGE-A10_254–262-specific CD8⁺ T cells in polyclonal cultures and at the clonal level. The results indicate that the repertoire of MAGE-A10_254–262-specific CD8⁺ T cells is diverse both in terms of clonal composition, efficiency of peptide recognition, and tumor-specific lytic activity. Importantly, only CD8⁺ T cells able to recognize the antigenic peptide with high efficiency are able to lyse MAGE-A10-expressing tumor cells. Under defined experimental conditions, the tetramer staining intensity exhibited by MAGE-A10_254–262-specific CD8⁺ T cells correlates with efficiency of peptide recognition so that “high” and “low” avidity cells can be separated by FACS. Altogether, the data reported here provide evidence for functional diversity of MAGE-A10_254–262-specific T cells and will be instrumental for the monitoring of peptide MAGE-A10_254–262-based clinical trials.